Skip to content

Our Story

Healthy food for a healthy life. That's more than a tagline. It's our philosophy.

Our Heritage

A Historic Landmark

Café Evergreen calls home to the oldest building on US 41 between Venice and Tampa. Built in 1923, this beautiful structure served as the first Bank and Post Office in Sarasota County.

When we discovered this gem, we knew it was special. We've lovingly preserved its historic character while creating a warm, welcoming space where our community can gather and enjoy nourishing food.

Every brick, every beam tells a story. And now, it's the backdrop for a new chapter: healthy, delicious meals that bring people together.

Historic 1923 building - Café Evergreen
1923
Est. Building
Annette and Ted, owners of Café Evergreen
Welcome to Café Evergreen

A Passion for a Healthy Lifestyle

Our personal philosophy is to be a leader in healthy foods and drinks that are fresh, great tasting and unique. We take things that people like and give them a healthier option, all the time maintaining quality and great taste.

People love French fries — our healthy version is baked sweet potato fries. We don't even have a fryer at the café, which makes for a much more creative type of cooking. Look at most restaurant menus and count the fried items.

Our food is more vibrant and colorful because it is fresh. When you use fresh ingredients, there is always a taste difference.

Enjoy! — Annette & Ted

“Locally Sourced & Organic Oriented”

We are constantly buying from and helping local businesses and organic farmers.

Since we opened Café Evergreen we have always respected where our food is sourced. Our goal is to nourish our community and our environment with a sustainable system, promote education about what we consume, and serve the freshest food and drinks from local ingredients — using the fields around us as the chef's pantry.

Our Philosophy

To Live Well is to Eat Well

“Eat well, look good, feel great!”

No Fryer

We don't have a fryer on premises. Every dish is thoughtfully prepared using healthier cooking methods that preserve nutrients and flavor.

Low Sodium

We use two-thirds less salt than most restaurants. Because our sauces, soups and dressings are made in house, we control the salt — canned and pre-made sauces lean on it as a cheap preservative.

Organic & Local

We source locally and choose organic ingredients whenever possible. No GMO, no preservatives. Just real food from real farms.

House-Made

Our sauces, soups, and dressings are made fresh daily in our kitchen. You can taste the difference that scratch cooking makes.

Dietary Friendly

Vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free. We welcome all dietary needs and take allergies seriously. Everyone deserves a delicious meal.

Community First

We're not just a restaurant. We're a gathering place for neighbors, families, and friends. That's why we've served this community for years.

Recognition

Award-Winning Quality

We're humbled and honored by the recognition we've received from our community.

8
Consecutive years

Best Organic Restaurant in Venice

2014–2021

2
Consecutive years

Best Salads in Venice

2020–2021

1st
In the USA

Best Vegetarian Sandwich — the Evergreen Club

Restaurant Hospitality

#1
Of 29 in Nokomis

Ranked first by travellers

TripAdvisor, 568 reviews

Also voted Best Organic Restaurant by Natural Awakenings in 2013, named Best Venice Restaurant by Sarasota Magazine in 2021, and awarded a TripAdvisor Certificate of Excellence in 2015.

Signature Specialty

The Kefir Mojito

We are the only ones in the whole world who can make this drink. Our water kefir grains have been exclusively grown and nurtured by us for over ten years, and they give this probiotic drink a one-of-a-kind flavour. It is non-alcoholic, and there is nothing else like it.

It's a perfect example of how we approach everything we do: thoughtfully, patiently, and with your health in mind.

Come Visit Us

We'd love to welcome you to our historic home. Taste the difference that healthy, thoughtful cooking makes.